Ryan-
FWIW in college we made a pulling tractor using a 17T, 18T, and 19T pulling gear plus reverse. We bought the gears through True Gear & Spline in Canada. There's a couple things you have to do, none for the faint of heart (they're not as hard as they are time consuming in the machine shop). First, you'll need the 4-speed shifting forks from SuperCub, nice pieces if I might say so. You'll also need to either buy or make the spacers for the lower shaft. Pretty easy. BUT then you'll need to make (at least we did) your own shifting rods and machine the detents. It's not too bad, but we made two pair before we got it right. You'll have to change the reverse idler so it sits towards the back of the tranny, while you're in there you'll probably need to grind some out of the front of the case where the smaller gear for third sat in the front, I think we put the 19T gear in front and just removed about a quarter-inch of material to make the lower gear fit. ALSO, while you're at it you'll probably want to get the aftermarket top shaft.
Also, note the design of the transmission, lower gears closer to the pinon gear, higher towards the front, avoid putting your first gear towards the front as you're putting more torque through more of the pinon shaft.