Matt,
Sorry about the loss of your tools. That is a huge blow to an established shop. And you are right - real hard to remember all the tools you had and only used once in a while. Take your time, think about past and present projects, look through the sears tool catalog, and on and on......
The point is, all those tools, accessories, etc. will take real money to replace, and you've been paying insurance just for that purpose! Now the question is whose money? Yours or the insurance companies? (that gets their money from you!) I've been there -- they can badger you, pressure you, demand a final list, question you -- anything to avoid paying you. Good luck.
On topic - no cub time at all. a real downer. flue since Christmas morning - we've had beautiful warm sunny weather and I haven't even had the strength to walk the dogs.